According to Apartment List’s March 2023 Rent Report, following five consecutive months of month-over-month reductions, rent growth turned positive again in February, albeit by just 0.3 percent countrywide.
Notwithstanding that small accomplishment, the underlying picture for landlords in the near future is less than favorable.
According to the survey, this year may be the first time since the early days of the epidemic that landlords are vying for tenants rather than the other way around.
The report states that there are more multifamily units being built right now than there have ever been since 1970.
In contrast to the previous two years, when renters had to compete for a finite amount of available inventory, as this new inventory enters the market throughout the course of the year, property owners may be competing for tenants to fill their units.
The demonstrated rental growth resembles that of February before the outbreak. Rent growth is slowing year over year and has reached its lowest point since April 2021, at 3%. According to Apartment List, it is projected to “fall more” in the upcoming months.
Vacancies now stand at 6.4%, and supply is decreasing. In February, rents rose in 62 of the top 100 cities in the country.
The research states that supply limitations will continue to ease because a record number of multifamily housing units are now being built.
No major metro region in the nation has had positive rent growth during the past six months.
With a 1.5 percent increase, Boston experienced the fastest rent growth in the country.
Although it continues to be one of the nation’s slowest rental markets when assessed over the course of the pandemic as a whole, the Boston metro area ranks among the top 10 for quickest year-to-year rent growth, according to the research.
According to Apartment List, the vacancy rate might even go above that pre-pandemic level for the remaining months of 2023.
According to the study, new apartment development has resumed after experiencing delays due to pandemics in recent years.
The SVN Vanguard team knows investors need an experienced commercial property management company by their side. Contact us for multifamily properties for sale.
The Los Angeles City Council adopted important renter safeguards on Friday, including one that establishes nationwide just-cause eviction provisions. As a result, the city’s apartment stock is now the second-largest collection of regulated housing in the nation.
February 1st, 2023 | Los Angeles, CA
The hearings over the last week have revealed that renters have more council allies than ever before and that this group is prepared to take action.
Two of the suggested safeguards have not yet been put to a formal vote, but one significant safeguard for tenants has. There are now only roughly 14 grounds for eviction of a tenant due to the development of just-cause safeguards for renters. These laws shall be applicable to all rentals in the City of Los Angeles, including single-family residences and newly constructed apartments, as indicated by the term “universal.” The new rule is now in effect because it was passed with an urgency clause.
These safeguards are comparable to those that presently apply to the estimated 650,000 rent-stabilized homes in the city, but according to the city’s housing authority, these new regulations will also apply to an additional 400,000 units. A housing department official informed the council on Friday that the city will have the largest inventory of controlled housing in the nation, excluding New York City, with more than 1 million units.
The lifting of the eviction moratorium has brought comfort to many landlords, albeit short-lived with this introduction of new limitations on how they can conduct business.
Aaron Cohen, Chief Operating Officer of CGI+ Real Estate Strategies, expressed excitement about the conclusion of the eviction moratorium at the end of January.
But according to Cohen, these additional renter protections that aim to mimic the impact of the eviction moratorium will put a cost on landlords that they shouldn’t have to bear.
“It was never the right solution to me, to say ‘Let’s force landlords to take the burden of this,’” Cohen said. “It doesn’t make any sense to me. ” He vehemently disagrees that landlords should be forced to arbitrarily bear this responsibility at random.
Cohen pointed out that even after the moratorium on evictions expires, tenants can only be evicted for failing to pay their current rent, not for any rent they owe during the time between 2020 and the end of the moratorium. Tenants have 12 months to make those payments.
Landlord Joyce Mitchell called into the council’s housing and homelessness committee meeting on Wednesday and stated, “We feel we have no representation with this city council.” She claims that small-property owners of color, like herself, stand to lose everything as a result of the eviction moratorium and additional laws since they have invested their retirement funds in their homes.
According to Mitchell, it’s past time to stop holding mom-and-pop apartment owners accountable for the fact that the city and county elected authorities have done nothing about the homeless epidemic in this community. Mitchell added, “We will be the next wave of homelessness in this city if you continue to treat us this way.”
Research demonstrates that eviction safeguards helped keep people housed throughout the crucial period of the pandemic, according to tenant advocates and renters. These supporters contend that maintaining renters in their housing shouldn’t end with the pandemic’s emergency phase in a city where a sizable portion of the population is homeless.
Nithya Raman, a council member whose district includes Encino, Silverlake, and Los Feliz, described the additional safeguards as the most significant since the establishment of the Rent Stabilization Ordinance in a tweet on Friday.
Before the end of this week, the council is expected to hear from the two last components of the renter safety net. The other would establish a minimum amount of time that would need to pass before tenants could be removed for nonpayment. The first would mandate that landlords provide basic relocation assistance for tenants who move out because they have experienced a rent rise of 10% or more.
Sasha Harnden, the public policy advocate with the Inner City Law Center, said, “We must put the two remaining permanent protections in place so that we can have a really full safety net of protections and make sure that we do not see a rise in evictions and homelessness.”
According to Harnden, only those two safety net components can effectively address rent and renters in the future. In the event that they are put into effect, “we will have the strongest protections for non-payment evictions in the county of Los Angeles, maybe in the entire nation,” he claimed.
In a way that we haven’t seen in a while, according to Harden, the council’s five new members have demonstrated genuine leadership and real engagement with these issues.
Although Cohen said he doesn’t expect these new laws to have a significant impact on his firm, he does claim that they raise the cost of doing business in the city, which is counterproductive in a city where more affordable housing is desperately needed.
In contrast to essentially forcing landlords to accept the loss, Cohen urged municipal authorities to really go the route of figuring out ways that charitable organizations pay for unpaid rent in order to help property owners pay these outstanding debts.
The SVN Vanguard team knows investors need an experienced commercial property management company by their side. Contact us for multifamily properties for sale/lease.
The quarterly sentiment index published by the CRE Finance Council shows a significant increase in Q4 2022. This marks the first sentiment increase since 2021.
The report, which includes balance sheet and securitized lenders, loan and bond investors, private equity companies, debt funds, servicers, and rating agencies, found that overall sentiment climbed to 68.6 last quarter. From 61.4 in the third quarter, which was the lowest level since the survey’s start in 2017. The jump represents an increase of 12%.
Despite progress in the right direction, the index is still in the negative due to the ongoing anxiety surrounding inflation, rising interest rates, and an impending recession, according to analysts with the CRE Financial Council. In addition, lenders and investors may have more difficulties in the upcoming year due to the uncertainties surrounding property valuation.Individual survey response rates were flat to somewhat better, with the biggest gains in the following areas: investor demand for assets, borrower demand for capital, and market liquidity in the CRE debt capital markets.
According to Raj Aidasani, Senior Director of Research at CREFC, members’ expectations for improved liquidity conditions increased by 18% in the fourth quarter of 2022. In Q3, 62% of respondents predicted a decrease in liquidity, while only 8% predicted an increase. However, in Q4, 18% predict better conditions while 47% predict a decline.In addition, the rising rate environment continues to weigh heavily, with 84% of respondents anticipating rates will have a negative impact on the industry in the current quarter, compared to 98% in the prior quarter, according to Aidasani.
Knowing when and where to pivot is critical in 2023 as unpredictability and market rebalancing is to be expected.
According to a new Hines study, each cycle has its own peculiarities, so investors, owners, and operators shouldn’t totally rely on what happened in the past.
The firm wrote: “Recognizing what is different and what may at least rhyme with previous cycles can provide insight into how to navigate what is both challenging, with regard to existing holdings, and opportunistic, with regard to the potential to deploy capital in a more sober and attractive pricing environment.”
The “shortage of broader seller capitulation thus far,” which GlobeSt.com has also referred to as a lack of current price discovery, and the rising pricing pressure of financing (if it is even available at all) are two elements at play. Defensively maintaining capital and hunting for possibilities will differ by global area.
Although the industrial and multifamily markets’ bidding pools are narrower than they were at the beginning of 2022, they are still healthy. “Commodity Class A office is fairly illiquid at the end of the year” in the United States.
According to Hines, there are two main signs to pay attention to. The change volume of transactions usually always comes first. “We can observe the historical association between volume and price rise with a longer time series of transaction volume in the U.S. spanning numerous cycles,” they stated. Unfortunately, the link occurs at the same time rather than before, but the stabilization of transaction volume and ensuing increase during previous cycles has been a solid sign that prices hit a bottom and should start to rise if volume continues to return, says the author.
According to information obtained by GlobeSt.com from a number of sources, there is already an expectation that transaction volumes may start to change shortly because there is a lot of capital sitting on the sidelines ready for deployment. However, just like markets, that will probably differ greatly by region. Focusing on regional transaction numbers is more likely to indicate whether certain markets are likely to present an opportunity than sticking with keeping an eye on national transaction volumes.
The second indicator is an increase in traditional debt availability. According to the Federal Reserve’s Loan Officer Survey conducted in the third quarter, “57.6% of respondents reported tighter underwriting standards for commercial real estate loans, including loans for construction and land development; 52.9% for non-farm, non-residential loans; and 39.7% for multifamily properties.” When banks reported lowering their requirements in the second half of 2021, all three categories registered a significant increase from a year ago.
With inflation being chased by interest rate increases from the Federal Reserve, the present economic situation has been challenging. The Fed has indicated that additional rate rises are still expected, even though some of the pressures may have passed their peak. Lenders to corporations are taking the risk-averse approach, tightening their requirements and reducing the available leverage.
According to the managing director and head of net lease real estate at Angelo Gordon, Gordon J. Whiting, a mortgage lender will typically give 75% to 80% of the loan-to-value of the property. Whiting adds, “In today’s macroeconomic conditions, it’s much harder to get access to capital, it’s harder to get a loan, and you’re only getting 60%.”
There is added benefit in securing a strategy with certainty, especially given the uncertain nature of the future and the possibility of rising interest rates. Many would agree, doing a sale-leaseback and paying off some of the more expensive or adjustable-rate debt is preferable. The more liquidity you have on hand, the simpler it is to deal with unforeseen events.Working Capital is Paramount Today
Sale-leasebacks are an excellent source of purchase financing, especially given the current state of the market, which in some cases is conducive to strategic add-on acquisition prospects. Profits from sale-leaseback transactions can be used by businesses to support new acquisitions or platform expansion. The money from a sale-leaseback that was completed at the time of acquisition might be used by sponsors to reduce their capital costs for the transaction.
Whiting believes that the market uncertainty and potential for future rate hikes are additional sources of risk and that a sale-leaseback should be considered as soon as possible. He adds that we are in a situation where you’ll wish you had done it the day before rather than the day after.
A little encouraging news on inflation, but probably not enough to cause the Fed to change its course just yet.
The usual metric that is used, the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), actually decreased by 0.1% in December 2022, increasing by 6.5% from the previous year. This is a decrease from the 7.1% change year over year in November. Numerous publications claim that the decline was consistent with mainstream projections.
Overall, that’s a great indicator since it indicates that prices are actually starting to decline rather than merely slowing off. Things become more chaotic as you go deeper. Energy expenses decreased by 4.5%, which was mostly the result of dropping gasoline prices. However, the price of food, which cannot be disregarded, increased by 0.3% between November and December, which immediately puts a strain on the wallets of typical customers.
After rising by 0.2% in November, the core inflation index—which measures all goods except food and energy—rose by 0.3% in December. Inflation was even worse in this regard.Shelter, or houses and multifamily buildings, was a significant factor. In November, it had increased by 7.1% year over year, and in December, it had increased by 7.5%. Fuel oil (for buildings that use it to heat) and energy services both stood out in the 12-month price growth rate at 41.5% and 15.6%, respectively.
The Federal Open Market Committee is expected to raise the target range for the fed funds rate by 25 basis points at their upcoming meeting, Oxford Economics predicted in an email. “The December CPI is another small step in the right direction, but it doesn’t alter our forecast,” Oxford Economics said. The Fed will want proof that they have stopped inflation and that it is returning to their 2% aim, so this probably won’t be the last rate increase this cycle. The reaction to the December CPI in the financial markets and Fed Funds futures was rather modest.
And as Bill Adams, chief economist for Comerica Bank, said in emailed remarks, “Inflation should continue to decrease in 2023, allowing the Fed to suspend rate hikes this spring and begin to progressively cut rates in the fall.” However, the economy was already deteriorating towards the end of 2022, and in 2023 it would probably go through a slight recession.
One potential worry for the CRE housing sector is that housing costs continue to be a significant contributor to inflation and outsized growth. This may make customers angry and bitter, and it might even prompt requests for further control.
The SVN Vanguard team knows investors need an experienced commercial property management company by their side. Contact us for commercial properties for sale and lease.
The current shift in many markets toward steady and even declining rents has an impact on multifamily investments and individuals who own apartment buildings.
In addition, landlords are in a unique position compared to other run-ups because inflation is currently rising faster than rents, which could provide difficulties for buyers when working with their lenders.
According to Jamie Berenger, chief credit officer at A10 Capital, the multi-family industry has seen a disproportionate amount of capital invested recently when compared to other asset classes. This sector is seen as a safe haven for real estate investment.
Buyers had to anticipate large, ongoing rental rate growth in order to “pencil” agreements, according to the increase in capital-chasing transactions, she claimed. Should they materialize, a fall in rent growth predictions could lead to extended or, in more extreme cases, missed business plans.
A lack of rent growth will put pressure on stabilized (takeout) indicators, especially on transitional assets secured with bridge loans, which will create a divergence between lenders and borrowers in the future.
Rents are rising faster than expenses.
We are going to continue to see a cooling in the multifamily market, especially in the places that were overheated in 2022 (Florida, Tennessee, Nevada, Arizona, etc.).
Rents and sales will continue to decline as the economy continues to be affected by inflation and interest rates, which Bechtel predicted would likely continue until the third or fourth quarter before the Fed starts to taper.
I believe that a recession is already underway, particularly when you consider benchmarks like a flat or inverted yield curve, long-term U.S. Treasury bonds with a yield over 3%, and negative growth over the last two quarters.
Operating expenses will certainly increase due to inflation, which could have an effect on property values if the landlord is unable to pass these costs on to tenants in the form of higher rent.
In some circumstances, the increase in expenses is surpassing the rise in rent for the first time in many years, leading to a decline in NOI growth. You might observe rising capitalization rates together with declining sales, which could further decrease values.
Rent Growth Forecast is Being Reduced
According to a story this week by GlobeSt.com, at least two apartment rent analysis organizations recently lowered their projections for 2023.
RealPage has revised its effective asking rent growth prediction for 2023 downward to 3%, with rent movement differing considerably by asset type and by submarket.
Yardi Matrix anticipates all of that growth to occur in the first two to three quarters of the year and has reduced its apartment rent projection for 2023 downward to 3.1% from 3.5%.
Beginning in 2023, Los Angeles will face increasing challenges that threaten to prevent economic recovery.
According to information provided by a major firm, the office vacancy rate increased once again in the fourth quarter, while apartment rents decreased somewhat. Additionally, investment across all asset classes has slowed down due to increasing interest rates.
The L.A. commercial real estate industry is expected to undergo challenges as the economy responds to changes in supply, demand, and pricing going into 2023, according to said research. Difficulties in borrowing money lead to less expenditure, which lowers real estate values while the Federal Reserve keeps raising interest rates.
The Federal Reserve is slowing down the economy in an effort to combat inflation by raising interest rates, but it’s clear that strategy is starting to have an effect on commercial real estate. The market is showing rising vacancy and falling rents, with the exception of industrial rent, which has held steady. It’s predicted that in the new year, each type of property will face its own chances and difficulties.
Office
Landlords are reporting reductions in occupancy rates due to a larger migration to quality assets as well as significant cutbacks in the tech and media industries, which have for years been major drivers in L.A. Larger office tenants are cutting excess space and reevaluating overall workspace needs, but most experts are in agreement that the sector is still on a “slow path to recovery.”
Demand for office space decreased even as the vacancy rate increased 110 basis points from the previous year to 15.2 percent in the third quarter of 2022. At $3.48 per square foot, the average asking rent was just slightly lower (less than 5 cents) than it was at the beginning of the year.
The research stated that landlords will become creative in recruiting tenants to occupy unoccupied space, offering advantageous concessions including flexible lease terms, free rent, and tenant improvement allowances.
Multifamily
Multifamily vacancy increased somewhat by 10 basis points year over year to 3.7 percent in the fourth quarter following a spike in development. According to a leading local firm, typical asking rent decreased for the first time since the pandemic shutdown. This was still 3.2 percent higher than it was in 2017.
The report stated that the change in market dynamics and demand for multifamily housing will persist beyond 2023. Rising borrowing rates, escalating construction costs, and a sluggish economy will influence the rate of growth for multifamily units, which seek stability.
Retail
While the average asking rent increased over the same period, retail vacancy rates were unchanged from a year earlier at 5.4 percent in the fourth quarter, despite some businesses returning to brick-and-mortar locations.
It’s expected that retail will continue to evolve, with the majority of merchants holding less physical selling space in storefronts and more warehouse space for e-commerce, outdoor restaurant dining, and curbside pickup—a permanent change.
The SVN Vanguard team knows investors need an experienced commercial property management company by their side. Contact us for commercial properties for sale and lease.